I can't recall whether or not I've tasted Cornerstone Cellars wines, but their primary label includes Cab from Howell Mountain, so needless to say like many Napa stars it comes with a price tag beyond my usual range. So they also now produce the Stepping Stone label, with the goal of creating "memorable wines at Wednesday night prices" as they put it.
They have definitely hit the mark in terms of making good quality wines for the Stepping Stone label, and this lineup is relatively affordable by Napa standards. With prices ranging from $16-$35, they are not strictly speaking within my typical Wednesday night wine budget. But I would definitely consider them good values overall--the Sauvignon Blanc and the Syrah are the 2 I'd be most likely to pick up at the wine shop. Here's the summary of my tasting notes and some of the comments of our guests. With the exception of the Rose, they are all single varietals made from Napa Valley fruit.
2009 Stepping Stone Sauvignon Blanc, Cuvee Musque ($16) Light bouquet, I first tasted grapefruit and pine. Good structure, but the acidity was calling out for food--wished I'd had some pesto to go along with it. I did have guacamole and some goat cheese on hand--and nibbling this along with the SB definitely made me enjoy it more...not sure if it was just the effect of the food, and/or breathing a tad, but it definitely improved as I sipped more. I'd buy this to go with pesto for sure. The Cuvee Musque is a Sauvignon Blanc clone--I need to learn a little bit more about this, stay tuned...
2009 Stepping Stone Corallina Red Hills Lake County Rose ($16) People couldn't get their nose out of their glasses on this one, the bouquet alone was intoxicating! I got a touch of raspberry jam on this along with some dusky tones in the background. Definitely another good value. This one is a 50/50 blend of Grenache and Syrah.
2009 Stepping Stone Syrah ($20) This was perhaps my favorite, definitely felt it was the best value. This Syrah had a woodsy aroma, soft on the palate with nice cherry fruit, well-structured. Friends were picking up clover and cinnamon on this one. Really nice mouthfeel. This could work well with a lot of meat dishes.
2008 Stepping Stone Cabernet Franc ($30) Alas, it was well past midnight when I sampled this one, and the key phrase I get from my notes is "tasty". This has a lot of flavor and improves in the glass...it's only one of the lineup where I'd say it would do better with a bit of aging or decanting, as the breathing time in the glass rounded things out nicely. Wish I had another bottle to try it at a more reasonable hour...
2008 Stepping Stone Cabernet Sauvignon ($35) This was an interesting wine. I got vanilla tones along with berry fruit, and a nice long, pleasing finish. Other folks here used the term "sweet" to describe it. I usually think of a cab when I'm eating steak or some other such hearty fare. But this one was very pleasant to sip, but the vanilla/sweet element makes me think it might not do too great with steak. I'd be happy to drink more of it if it were given to me, but considering the price, it didn't compare well for me compared the rest of the Stepping Stone lineup in terms of value.
Overall, I'd say these are all good quality wines. Sometimes a tasting like this generates a consensus favorite, but different wines appealed to different group members. I'd say that's an indication that everything was of good quality and it was more a matter of personal preference as to what people picked as a favorite.
The ones that come in at $20 are values I'd definitely consider buying. While I enjoyed the two that were over $30, I feel I might do better for the same price on other wines (thinking about a number of good bottles I've had from the Pacific Northwest lately). I'd also be interested in trying something from the Cornerstone lable following this tasting...I'd even sign up for another 11:30 p.m. tasting!
Full disclosure: these wines were sent as a complementary sample from the winery as part of the Taste Live program.


